Skip to main content

Is It A Sheppard's Or A Cottage Pie? That Is The Question!





We all have family favorites and comfort foods; one of my all-time favorites is Sheppard's/ Cottage pie. This takes me back to my childhood; it is easily digestible and warming from the inside out.
Actually traditionally Sheppard's pie is made using minced lamb, and cottage pie typically was made with a crust of mashed potato at the bottom, the layer of minced beef in between and a layer of mashed potato on top. It was the dish of rural farmers in Britain first recorded in 1791 when potatoes were considered edible crop.

In my childhood there were many different varieties of this quintessentially British nursery food; my paternal grandmother made it the traditional way with lamb, in thick onion gravy, my maternal grandmother used minced beef, topped with a thick layer of ultra-creamy mashed potatoes. My mother added carrots, and one aunt baked beans to their basic meat mixture,  while another aunt would top the mashed potato with grated cheddar cheese and crushed potato crisps for that extra fat and calorie value! Looking back I can't say whose version I preferred but as this is nearest to my mother's I guess with hindsite that speaks volumes.

Over the years I have come to the conclusion that there almost as many versions of Sheppard's pie as people making it and it boils down to personal choice. Last week my friend presented me with Sheppard's pie with a mashed cauliflower topping It was really wonderful especially for those watching their carb intake.

HERE IS MY VERSION OF A RICH AND HEALTHY FAT REDUCED COULD BE A COTTAGE OR A  SHEPPARD'S PIE.

4-6 people   You need
3/4 of a kilo (750 grams) good quality Minced beef
1 leek cleaned and chopped finely
3 cloves garlic chopped
2 bay leaves
3 carrots peeled and diced
2 stalks celery peeled and diced
1 tea spoon cacao
1 large onion chopped finely
1 dessert spoon organic   sugar free tomato ketchup
1 pint of good stock, preferably chicken of beef, or vegetable with a teaspoon of marmite
1 teaspoon thyme leaves (dried)
1/4 teaspoon cinnamon
1/2 teaspoon Non ionized sea salt
1/2 teaspoon fresh  ground black pepper.
1 teaspoon coconut oil melted.

Heat the coconut oil in a thick bottom pot, and add the onion and garlic, then the carrots leeks and celery, bay leaf place a lid on the pot cook on a medium heat and cook for 10 minutes so all the aromatic flavors come through.
Add the meat, thyme and mix well, cook on a low heat till the meat is browned, then add your cacao and cinnamon these both bring out the flavor of the beef. 
Add your stock, and your organic   tomato ketchup or paste season to taste. Reduce to a low heat, and simmer for about 40 minutes, 30 with the lid and the last 10 minutes without to reduce the stock down.

For the topping you need.
2 kilos sweet potato
1 large red skin potato
1/4 cup almond or Coconut milk its best with coconut milk
1 teaspoon coconut oil
Freshly ground black pepper  sea salt to taste.
Peel and chop all the potatoes, place them in a large pan of boiling water with a pinch of salt. Cook for 10-15 minutes till soft,
Drain all the water, season well, add the coconut oil and mash well, then add the coconut milk to the potato mixture and mix.
Set aside to cool,
At this stage you can assemble the pie or wait till both the meat and the potato mixture have cooled a bit to make for easier to handle.

To Assemble The Cottage/ Sheppard's Pie.

Preheat the oven to 190ºC/375ºF/gas 5

Choose your dish wisely.. I use a deep Pyrex, so that one can see the division of the pie at the table, but my mother use to use a deep oval metal pie dish…I just know that once a family adopts a certain recipe and dish it becomes the family favorite.
Your meat mixture should be juicy but not runny, ( and certainly not dry) so you can take off any excess fluid and set it aside to serve as gravy .
Place the meat mixture in the dish spread evenly.
Top with the sweet potato making sure you spread the potatoes to the very edge therefore sealing in all the meat juices.
Take a fork and ruffle the top.
Ruffle the top  with a  fork to create peaks

(At this stage you can freeze the pie up to a month,  defrost totally  then continue  as below.)

Bake for 25-30 minutes till the top goes golden and the meat mixture is bubbling at the edges.
I always let mine stand for 5-6 minutes before serving so the layers settle.

Serve on its own, or with a variety of vegetables. (I like cauliflower cabbage or swede!)


I am a real lover of Shepherds /Cottage pie, the name is of no importance to me; one bite takes me back to winter suppers of my childhood, there is no right or wrong way to make it, but I hope you enjoy my simple version that I guarantee will warm you up from within while enveloping you in a feeling of tranquility and comfort of times gone by.   





Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Not Schmaltz At All ( healthy chopped liver)

Chopped liver often mocked, reproduced and joked about, as traditionally Jewish as chicken soup.  Chopped liver can be made with any type pf liver but personally I prefer the traditional  favorite of chicken livers. Chopped liver was traditionally fried in schmaltz (chicken fat ) which over the years has given way to oil, my no fry no oil version tastes just as good but weight watchers can eat with guilt. Nutritional Value Liver is a nutrient-rich food and the ingredients in the chopped liver recipe add more nutrients to the mix. Liver is high in vitamin A, which is dangerous to unborn babies so pregnant mothers should avoid liver in any form.It also contains  vitamin C  choline,  betaine, of vitamin B-12,  retinal and vitamin E  also  of vitamins B-6, folate, niacin, pantothenic acid, riboflavin and thiamin in lesser amounts It also contains the following minerals  Its high in i ron, magnesium,  phosphorus,  potassium,  zinc,  copper, manganese  selenium . If eaten frequently,
  Perfect Hot Salt Beef Sandwich When I was twenty I was lucky enough to work a stall in the world famous   Petticoat Lane market   on   Sunday   mornings, Back in the day the market was mainly Jewish market traders   we were part of the very special history of the East End of London, The excitement, hustle and bustle, comradeship between the stall holders was second to none, we worked all weathers , and shared each other’s joys and sorrows.   but the icing on the cake was visiting Blooms on Whitechapel Road after trading had finished for a succulent hot salt beef sandwich, nothing can erase these memories from my mind even though its over half a century ago. When Danny Brummer  “Z"L”  was running the Deli in Hove Street, I use to cook with him, back in the day we use to pickle our own beef but nowadays you can buy it ready pickled from Gilberts, this is the recipe we used to serve hot salt beef sandwiches to the Brighton and Hove Jewish community   1.5 kilos ready pickle
 Beef Pot Roast for 4 Pot roast is the ultimate winter meal, that is so easy to prepare and full of flavor and satisfying, it is equally good for a family meal or to serve to guests. You can cook it the traditional method or in a slow cooker! The results are equally as good, but a slow cooker is more economical. The hardest thing about this recipe is gathering all the ingredients! Ingredients 1 kilo chuck roast, round roast, or briskets. Ask your butcher to roll it for you 2 cloves garlic peeled and chopped 2 bay leaf 2 red onions peeled and cut into ¼ 2 celery stalks cut into chunks 2 carrots cut into chunks 1 parsnip cut into chunks ½ swede cut into chunks I tin of chopped tomatoes 500ml red wine 250ml beef stock ½ teaspoon mixed herbs ½ cup fresh parsley ½ teaspoon brown sugar Salt and pepper to taste If cooking in the oven – Preheat oven 160C/Gas 3/fan oven 140C Place the meat in a large Dutch oven (casserole dish) Place the vegetables garlic, bay leaves and herbs around the beef.